Jeff
Benziger
April 22, 2004
Twenty-six stores out of 100 in Stanislaus County will illegally sell
cigarettes to minors, according to a California Department of Health Services
survey. That rate is double the statewide rate of 12.2 percent.
In response, a local committee plans in May to ask the Board of Supervisors
to implement a county ordinance designed to put teeth into enforcing the
law.
The proposed ordinance would require stores which sell cigarettes to
obtain a permit which costs $100. The permit would be revoked if the store
was caught selling cigarettes to minors on more than one occasion.
"Something has to be done to get our local merchants to stop selling
cigarettes to our children," said Kerrie Valenzuela of the Valley
Lode branch of the American Lung Association of California.
The $100 charged for a permit would be used to fund tobacco buy programs,
said Tim Bomgardner, a member of the Stop Tobacco Sales to Youth Committee.
The target would be to conduct at least three sting programs per year.
Under the proposed ordinance, a merchant would get a 30-day suspension
- which can be avoided by attending a special class - the first time caught
selling any tobacco product to anyone underaged. The second offense would
result in a 60-day suspension and payment of a new fee for another license.
The third offense would result in a year-long suspension of the license
and repayment of license fees. A fourth violation would result in a revocation
with the possibility to get another license in five years.
Selling tobacco without a license would be a misdemeanor.
Valenzuela believes that some store owners care more about profits than
adhering to the law. Those who are caught only pay a fine of $200, she
said. Others may just be careless, she offered.
"I just don't think it's enough," she said. "Especially
if they don't feel there's any conseqences."
It's proposed that the county Department of Environmental Resources to
administer the program.
Bomgardner, also a Stanislaus County Sheriff's deputy, said the law has
changed the way law enforcement agencies may conduct a sting. It used
to be standard practice to send in a minor to attempt a cigarette purchase.
If the clerk sold the product, they would be cited. State legislators
saw that as causing the minor to break the law as well. Now, he said,
a merchant can be cited if he or she presents a pack or carton of cigarettes
to a minor for a sale and the minor walks away from the sale.
More than 30 cities in California have enacted special licenses for the
sale of tobacco products.
"We think a plan like this would get the attention of local tobacco
retailers that refuse to follow the law and common decency," said
Valenzuela. "Obeying the law is simple. Retailers need to check a
person's identification, calculate age and decline to sell tobacco to
children."
Although selling tobacco to minors is illegal, merchants who violate
the law mostly pay relatively small fines.
Proponents of the measure are concerned about data that shows that 200
children start smoking each day and that 90 percent of the 42,000 Californians
who die each year from smoking-related diseases got hooked on tobacco
products before they were 18.
Opponents of the measure believe that it not only calls for another layer
of government bureaucracy but that it's disguised as a tax increase.
Involved in the effort are private citizens and health services organizations
such as the American Cancer Society, American Lung Association, Doctors
Medical Foundation Fresh Outdoors Project.
Under the state's Stop Tobacco Access to Kids Enforcement (STAKE) Act,
citizens may report a merchant seen selling tobacco to minors by calling
1 (800) ASK FOR ID. The merchant is then placed on a complaint list and
will be subject to a buy sting by the state Food and Drug branch. - By
JEFF BENZIGER / Editor of The Ceres (Calif.) Courier
|